COMPARISON REVIEW : Maybelline Colossal Kajal vs Lorea`l Kajal Magique

Maybelline New York “the Colossal Kajal”
Vs
Loreal Paris “Kajal Magique”




The battle is Ooonnnn! Two of the most lethal weapons are out for the kill in the market!
And the best part is we have a clear winner.
It is Loreal Paris’ Kajal Magique !
ASK ME WHY? 
Because in the Beauty world  Paris can beat New York anytime ......Juuust kidding!!!

I have more logical reasons to proclaim Kajal Magique as the winner. 
Here are a few points which are good and not so good about the two…..











Maybelline New York
“the Colossal Kajal”



                     L’oreal Paris
“Kajal Magique”

  


Product type
Product type
Black
Kajal / kohl / eyeliner

Black
Kajal / kohl / eyeliner
Packaging
Packaging
Twistable plastic pen
with bright yellow body


Twistable plastic pen
with black and
fuschia pink body

Special Ingredients
Special Ingredients

Vitamin E






Year of launch
2011


Black mineral pigments
Vitamin E
Cocoa Butter
Olive Oil Esters
Vitamin C Derivative


Year of launch
2013

Price
Price
Rs 175/-

Quantity
0.35 g

Shelf life
24 months
Rs 245/-

Quantity
       0.35 g

      Shelf life
        30 months




Texture
Texture
Matte black



Creamy black (not too creamy)
Ease of application
Ease of application
Bit of a rough glide with tugging of my eyelids, not easy to get pigment on waterline either

A smooth glide with
 a creamy finish,
easy on the waterline
with rich black color
Effect on eyes
Effect on eyes
Mild burning and itching in eyes, watering of eyes


Felt a bit soothing on the waterline,
no particular feeling per se

Staying power
Staying power

On me it was 8-9 hrs


Some more points
Smudge Proof
Water Proof



On me it was 6-7 hrs


Some more points
Ophthalmologically tested
Smudge Proof
Water Proof
Non-Transferable
The Look
Matte Black Look



The Look
Creamy Black Kohl Effect







MY VERDICT
3/5
Should have been creamier and non-irritating to eyes
MY VERDICT
4/5
                      The winner !

Creamy, intense black,
Non-smudging, non-irritating to eyes
With  ingredients full of goodness

'By IndianBeautyReviewer'

Recent Posts